Robots Atlas>ROBOTS ATLAS
Ethics & Law

Export control

2022ActivePublished: 18 November 2026Updated: 18 November 2026Published
Key innovation
Shifting AI competition to the hardware layer: instead of regulating models or data, export controls restrict physical access to advanced compute (GPUs/accelerators) and the tools used to manufacture it, treating chips as a geopolitical lever.
Category
Ethics & Law
Abstraction level
Pojęcie
Operation level
Law and governance
Use cases
AI geopoliticsCompute governanceRestricting access to AI accelerators (GPUs)Semiconductor supply-chain controlEnforcement against chip smuggling and reexportTechnology sanctions

How it works

1) Set technical thresholds (Total Processing Performance, performance density, and from 2024 HBM memory-bandwidth density) that define which chips are controlled. 2) Add goods to the Commerce Control List and require licenses for export to target countries (with a “presumption of denial”). 3) Extend reach via the Foreign Direct Product Rule — control also covers items made outside the U.S. if they were produced using U.S. technology or software. 4) Entity List — named lists of entities subject to tightened licensing requirements. 5) Enforcement: customs checks, penalties, prosecution of smuggling and transshipment, and monitoring of reexport.

Problem solved

How can a state limit a geopolitical rival's access to the most advanced AI capabilities without directly regulating models or data? Export control answers this by targeting a chokepoint — the physical compute hardware and its supply chain, which is highly concentrated among a few suppliers (NVIDIA, TSMC, ASML).

Components

Performance thresholds (TPP / performance density)Define the material scope of the controls.

Measurable technical criteria defining which compute chips are controlled. Total Processing Performance (TPP) and performance density let the controls capture new, more powerful chips without rewriting the whole regulation.

Commerce Control List and licensingThe permissioning and transaction-blocking mechanism.

The list of controlled goods and the requirement to obtain an export license, often with a “presumption of denial” for recipients in target countries.

Foreign Direct Product Rule (FDPR)The extraterritorial reach of the controls.

A rule extending U.S. jurisdiction to items produced abroad if they were made using U.S. technology, software, or equipment.

Entity ListTargeting of specific named entities.

Named lists of entities (companies, institutions) subject to tightened licensing requirements; roughly 140 entities were added in December 2024.

HBM memory-bandwidth density thresholdExtends control from chips to memory.

A threshold added in December 2024 that brings high-bandwidth memory (HBM), critical to AI accelerator performance, under control.

Evolution

2022
First export controls on advanced AI chips (BIS)
Inflection point

On 7 October 2022 BIS introduced controls covering advanced computing chips (including NVIDIA A100, H100) and Chinese semiconductor fabs. Published in the Federal Register on 13 October 2022.

2023
Loophole-closing update (A800/H800)
Inflection point

The October 2023 update captured chips engineered around the thresholds (NVIDIA A800 and H800), leading to the still-weaker H20 for the Chinese market.

2024
Extension to HBM and Entity List (+140 entities)

In December 2024, BIS extended the controls to HBM (bandwidth density) and added roughly 140 entities to the Entity List.

2025
15%-of-revenue-for-licenses arrangement (NVIDIA/AMD)

In August 2025, NVIDIA and AMD agreed to pay the U.S. government 15% of revenues from certain chip sales in China in exchange for export licenses; the same year the U.S. signalled action against smuggling and transshipment (Thailand, Malaysia).

Hyperparameters (configurable axes)

Performance threshold (TPP)Critical

The Total Processing Performance level above which a chip becomes controlled.

Performance densityHigh

A metric complementing TPP that makes it harder to evade thresholds by splitting performance.

HBM bandwidth densityMedium

The HBM memory-bandwidth density threshold introduced in December 2024.

Country scopeHigh

The set of target countries and groups (e.g. D:5) to which restrictions apply.

Licensing policyHigh

The default disposition of applications (e.g. “presumption of denial” vs. case-by-case review).